When it comes to comic canon and graphic novels there are a handful of seminal works, especially in the past 30 years. If you ask most fans, you will hear the following titles (not in order of importance)
- Dark Knight Returns
- V for Vendetta
- Sandman (Preludes and Nocturnes/Season of Mists)
- The Killing Joke
Alan Moore, Neil Gaiman, and Frank Miller are the men behind those titles. There are other titles that are up there as well, such as Powers, Preacher, Road to Perdition, Superman Red Son, All Star Superman, etc. The ones in the list though, they almost always make everyone’s lists. So when I heard that they were making The Killing Joke into a movie in the DC Animated Universe I was ecstatic. The DCAU has never failed to disappoint me and my regular readers have seen me reference them in multiple other reviews as the writing, animation, and just overall quality of work is impeccable.
So how did they do for this fan girl?
They are adapting the story from the Alan Moore Killing Joke, which pretty much changed the DC comic universe forever. Now, there are challenges here in this review as not everyone read the comic and I don’t want to spoil anything. Which is a challenge for me in this review as much as it was for Brian Azzarello who adapted the source material to screenplay. Azzarello last touched the animated scene with Batman: Gotham Knight (Working through Pain sequence), and beyond that has worked on DC Vertigo comics (same ones who gave us Sandman) and wrote some of the Wonder Woman New 52 run (which as I understand is praised). You see, up to this point the DCAU hasn’t introduced Barbara Gordon or Batgirl, so in order for this story to work they have to create a first act which focuses on her decisions, challenges, and the life she is living. This is a requirement as there is a population that has never really met her as they are only aware of what we have in the DCAU.
Do I agree with every decision they made? No. One of them was …ill conceived at best. Do I understand what they were trying to do with that decision? Yes. Overall, I think the first act is solid and if instead of the first act you consider it a ..prologue you will be fine. I understand a lot of reviewers have issues with it, and let’s be fair, I can equally see where they come from. I just disagree with them more than I disagree with Azzarello’s decisions on the screenplay.
Act II and III are the original material from the comic and are pretty much shot for shot and line for line. Director and Art Department Lead/Storyboard Artist Sam Liu made some wise choices in that aspect. You can absolutely tell how meticulously planned this was. Liu is no stranger to the DCAU, with several of the Batman films under his belt, including one of my favorites Assault on Arkham (it’s Suicide Squad just two years ago). You might be mistaken in thinking an animation directors job is easy. Consider that they, like their live action counterparts have to consider blocking, camera angles, how a shot moves. In fact, they have it both easier and harder. Easier in that they are not restricted by what visual effects can do or little things like physics; conversely they have to consider how the background painting, foreground, *and* characters move as they can all move independently of each other to give more motion to the narrative. I think this is one of the reasons the animated verse is so strong as they can tell a story that feels more epic and have to use every single tool at their disposal to the maximum effect, even little things like a squinted eye, a slouch, or putting your hands on another’s shoulders.
Voice acting. I will say this once. There is one Batman. His name is Kevin Conroy. You may think otherwise, but it’s ok to be wrong. You can grow from it. Mark Hamill is also the definitive voice of the Joker. Sure the live performances of Ledger, Nicholson, and Romero are legendary in their own rights, but Hamill just does it. There’s something alien about what his voice does and it lets you know you are in danger when you hear it. Troy Baker and John DiMaggio put their spin on it and do hold their own, but damnit Hamill *is* the Joker. Both he and Conroy have more screen time as their characters than anyone else in history, and likely will be reigning champions for time to come. Both also came out of retirement for the characters just to do *this* picture. That tells you how much it means to them as actors and how much they and the DCAU crew understand what it means to have them. We thank Andrea Romano and her rolodex of voice talent every time one of these comes out and this is no exception. These guys are absolutely on point here and get to share the dialogue and even a laugh that they never really did on Batman the Animated series, or the equally amazing Mask of the Phantasm. The other actors Tara Strong (normally Harley, this time Barbara) is as solid as ever, Ray Wise, John DiMaggio, Robin Atkin Downes, Nolan North, and others are fan favorites even in bit parts here and do what they need to; but once you are through Act I, …it’s Hamill and Conroy and nothing else matters.
Batman: The Killing Joke is amazing. It is everything I wanted it to be. It does have some flaws in the new material. It also should come with a trigger warning. This absolutely earned it’s R rating and it’s not for actual violence on camera – they’ve done worse. It’s what’s implied. What they don’t show mixed with what they hint at. Much like the original work, this is not for the faint of heart or those who are uncomfortable with certain topics. The movie makes you think, they bring up topics that you should think about when you consider The Batman, The Joker, and Jim Gordon. The utter insanity in the Joker is in full swing and I really question people who idolize him. He is chaos and evil personified.
This is absolutely *not* for children. Do not let a child watch this unless you are willing or want to have that conversation. Just be aware.
I am putting a spoiler section below, as I want to discuss one of the more controversial elements in the new material.
So should I watch it?
Whew…read above. This earned it’s R rating and is not ‘fun’ or ‘light’. I would watch this again and again, but I will need to be in the right mood for it. Like when I am wanting to write something really disturbing.
Will you buy it?
Technically for this one I had to, but I have no regrets not only buying the BluRay but the BluRay special edition.
What’s this spoiler?
Rollover to read….
Alright. So the first act focuses on Bab’s. It has to. Not everyone knows that Babs is Batgirl, or how she became Oracle. Or they only know in passing. The DCAU has barely dealt with her since the Batman Animated series. They have to tell this story to build up an emotional impact when she gets shot.
Did she have sex with the Bat? Here. Yes. The comic? No. Hell no. She was with Dick Grayson. Do I agree with her and the Bat having sex in this movie? No, but they made it clear it was something she wanted and as an adult it was her agency and her choice. I don’t think the Bat would ever go for it with someone under his wing and I do believe this is a departure from his character.
The painful and trigger warning part. Did the Joker sexually assault her? It’s up for debate in the comic and movie. It is *heavily* implied. Considering the earlier scenes are about her agency, and this is a violation of that of the worst kind. I know where I land on it. It is absolutely vile. It does remind you that the Joker is never a sympathetic villain, he is a monster of the worst kind. They do a good job in the movie of making the scene dark and yes disturbing without really having to show much of anything.
Is everything in the first act needed? Eh..no.
Is it the catastrophe I keep hearing about? Definitely not.
I’m surprised you didn’t touch on the production quality, since a number of critics seem to be harping on the animation.
I told you last night, but it felt a little clunky to me through the first act, but when act II starts up, it but me what they were doing. It’s an animated comic. Once I got that, I actually appreciated the art and animation more, since this seems like a concerted effort to look and feel a specific way.
The Foley work, as always, was amazing.
I thought about it honestly. I started watching other reviews after I completed mine and debated going back and updating. To your point when we watched and above, it’s an animated storyboard, but more. I consider Batgirl running across the roof. The Roof, the background, and she are moving independently. I also found the fluidity of the fight scenes on par with most of the other movies. Beyond that it is a touch jarring by comparison to other projects, but I also have a sneaking suspicion they were testing out new techniques as well with differing level of success on those techniques.
I consider BTAS season 1 vs season 4 vs say…Green Lantern Emerald Knights…and now this. There are stylistic differences, growth, and sometimes experimentation. It’s not that it’s better or worse than some animation – it’s just different than we are used to and maybe just not as pleasing when you have styles you prefer.
It’s not unlike comic’s themselves. I love the Hellboy story. I can’t read the comic as I am not a fan of the art style. Does it make it bad art? Should I criticize the art? No and No. It means it’s not my aesthetic. Clearly it is some people’s and thus they derive enjoyment from it. I could list a dozen comics (30 Days of Night, Kick Ass, Scott Pilgrim come to mind right away) that I don’t read because of art choice that don’t appeal. Does it degrade the quality of the overall piece? For me….I can’t appreciate the piece because I can’t get beyond the art. Those that like it enjoy it more for that.
It’s so much personal preference that I really didn’t feel the need unlike others.
And yes, the Foley work was incredible.
Reply fail. Refer to below comment, please.
Good call. To your point about the combat and movement, I think there was enough within the animation that we could as easily chalk it up to a stylistic choice rather than flat-out lack of quality. There was a point while watching it that I felt like I was watching BTAS again, and that to me is a VERY positive thing. It might rub others the wrong way, but I feel like criticizing it when the quality is there is a bit off-base.
But again, this is all one opinion.
Nah, it’s two opinions. There’s no inherent flaw in the animation when there is quality that is on par with most of their work. In fact it takes a less anime tone than some of the Justice League movies of late.